home | домой


News export

Всем неравнодушным
Мы помним и скорбим о безвременно погибших! И пусть власть не помнит, помнят простые граждане, которые могли оказаться ...
26/10/20 14:19 more...
author Ольга

Всем неравнодушным
Мы с вами! Сил всем пережившим и переживающим тот кошмар и его последствия. Я была подростком в 2002м, но хорошо всё пом...
26/10/20 04:14 more...
author Валерия

Памяти Сергея Карпова
Наш дорогой Сергей
Наш дорогой Сергей, Ты оставил нас, став жертвой пандемии Ковида 19, почти в ту самую дату, когда мы планируем собрат...
09/10/20 19:13 more...
author Kristian Maton - Robert Prospe

Памяти Сергея Карпова
Памяти Сергея Карпова
Светлая память замечательному человеку. Царствие Небесное. Не смогу сказать без слез нас обьединило огромное горе 18 лет...
07/10/20 08:13 more...
author Екатерина

Памяти Сергея Карпова
Отпевание Сергея Карпова состоится 8-го октября в Храме на Дубровке в 11-30
05/10/20 16:18 more...
author Светлана Губарева

Beslan. The memory is more terrible than forgetfulness
Written by Илья Сульдин   
Четверг, 05 Сентябрь 2013

On September 3rd, during the ninth anniversary of the tragic events in Beslan, an exhibition opened in the Arts Center on Michurin Street. This “upside down” exhibition was devised by a Samara artist named Frol Jolly, who became both curator of the project and one of its authors.


“This exhibition was a serious challenge for an artist,” stated Frol. “There's the temptation here to apply Theodor Adorno’s well-known phrase, that after the Holocaust one cannot write poetry. What can an artist add to the images of the faces of people who are carrying their blood children from the rubble? But in practice, the position ‘what can one add to this?’ is very easily converted into a permit to neither think, nor feel, nor enter into, nor discuss, nor interfere. With the installations and art objects that will be presented at the show, we have tried to visualize the events in Beslan and offer an artistic vision and interpretation of this tragedy.”

Knowing Frol, we note right away what Adorno said, and very fervently, but the exhibition works as no other Samara project has worked — people leave with “inverted heads”. Thus what he has created at the art center is really an organic art space, not a single, but a dual subordination of the terrible logic of the events. Undoubtedly the project that has opened at the Art Center deserves serious artistic and cultural analysis. It requires an analysis of the exhibition and even its use for «propaganda» purposes. Nine years is long enough for a generation to grow up not knowing what Beslan was. Therefore it should be required that classes of school children be brought here, as well as college students, as part of their patriotic education. It is much more effective than what the authorities offer us.

Suffice it to compare this piercing show with pictures of folksy happiness as created by Nina Dyukov at the festive event dedicated to the “Day of Anti-terrorism Solidarity”, which is celebrated coincidentally on September 3rd. just like Beslan. It was so much fun at the Philharmonic.



But here in the Art Center it is terrible. From the sight of naked, bloody children, from realizing the futility and horror of what is happening, and because of the fact that half of the not very large crowd at the exhibition even understands at first what is going on. Back then they were still in school. Frol has reminded them. It is rough, but it is what is appropriate here.

“03-09-2004 Beslan” is a very scary and difficult exhibition, because there are no specific conclusions; it just shows. It is as one-sided as anything made by people, and because of that Frol and all the other writers see the world from their own head and no other way. They use simple and powerful imagery. In places they beat the viewer over the head, or openly squeeze from him a tear. Especially since such straightforwardness does not harm our contemporary art, and every attempt to update a topic that is controversial, dangerous, and very painful is in itself very important and necessary.

And in the Art Center you can be sure that this attempt by Frol and other participants in the project has been successful. Young people really need to see this exhibition, but in reality (most likely), after a few short-lived days of work the crowds will be even smaller than on opening day, and on opening day, alas, it was not at all crowded. Doe no one wish to be shocked by art? Does no one see any parallels between what happened nine years ago and what is happening today? Or is there complete confidence that nothing like this will ever happen again in Russia? The exhibition did not mention this, but an investigation into the events at Beslan has never been completed, even now, nine years later.

In ‘Novaya Gazeta in the Volga region

Views: 4758 | E-mail

  Comments (1)
1. Норд Ост
Written by Василий website, on 30-10-2013 23:48
Создатель химического газа некто Гончаров Валерий Михайлович. Живёт на Щербинке в военном городке.

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.

Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.6
AkoComment © Copyright 2004 by Arthur Konze — www.mamboportal.com
All right reserved

< Prev   Next >