home |


News export

Panteleev, Denis
05/08/19 07:43 more...

Panteleev, Denis

. . ...
17/07/19 16:42 more...

Frolova, Dar'ya
, ... ...
18/05/19 17:13 more...

In memory of Politkovskaya
In memory of Politkovskaya
raise the voice on terrorism victims
10/05/19 11:18 more...
author bestro

Rozgon, Svetlana
, ) ...
06/05/19 05:54 more...

, 20 2011

(Applications nos. 18299/03 and 27311/03)


6. Rescue and evacuation operation


(c) Conclusions

263. Itis not possible for the Court to establish an individual story for each deceased hostage: where he or she was sitting when the operation began, how seriously he or she was affected by the gas and “concomitant factors” (stress, dehydration, chronic diseases etc.), what kind of treatment was received on the spot, at what time he or she arrived at a hospital, what kind of treatment he or she received in that hospital, etc.

264. Further, what is true in respect of the majority of the hostages may not be true in each individual case, taken alone. Thus, the alleged lack of medical aid would be irrelevant in a situation where a person had already died by the time the medics arrived. Equally, the Court cannot exclude that some of the victims were amongst those who were first to receive medical assistance but nevertheless died, because they were very weak or ill and died as a result of “a stroke of misfortune, a rare and unforeseeable occurrence” (see Giuliani and Gaggio, cited above, 192).

Will the Strasbourg Court's verdict?
, 21 2011

Will the Strasbourg Court's verdict unravel the mysteries of the 'Nord-Ost' tragedy?

9  Vladimir Kara-Murza: The Strasbourg court found Russia guilty of Human Rights violations during during the assault of Dubrovka in Moscow. While trying to rescue the 'Nord-Ost' hostages, the Russian authorities violated the right to life Article 2of the European Convention on Human Rights.

After 8years of litigation the Strasbourg court ruled that they had to pay 64plaintiffs compensation from 8thousand to 66thousand euros. Thiswas stated in an announcement by the ECHR, which was published on the organization's website.

Our citizens who turned to the court say that the Russian authorities used unreasonable force, did not provide timely medical assistance to the hostages, as well as ineffectively investigating the attack.

We are talking with Karinna Moskalenko about whether the Strasbourg court's verdict will unravel the mysteries of the 'Nord-Ost' tragedy. Moskalenko is the lawyer for the victims of the 'Nord-Ost' attack, while Elena Milashina is a columnist from 'Novaya Gazeta', and Dmitri Milovidov is an activist for the 'Nord-Ost' public organization. Whatis the meaning and principal value of the Strasbourg court's verdict?

Comments (1) | Views: 6659| E-mail

Russian security services guilty in the deaths of Nord-Ost
, 20 2011

Strasbourg reaches a decision on ‘Nord-Ost’. OnDecember 20th, the European Court of Human Rights almost fully satisfied claims by victims and relatives of the deceased victims of the terrorist attack on the theatrical center at Dubrovka.

The applicants themselves consider today’s decision by Strasbourg to be a real victory, and had been waiting for several years. Nowthey hope that an objective investigation into the incident will take place. Thevictims and relatives of the deceased hostages filed their claims with the European Court back in 2003.

In their petitions, they demanded that those who planned the hostage rescue operation be brought to justice. Thesecurity forces at the time released a poisonous gas into the auditorium where the audience and actors of the musical ‘Nord-Ost’ were being held hostage. Information about the gas is still a secret. Theplaintiffs believe that the use of this gas killed and injured not only the terrorists, but a large number of hostages aswell.

They also state that the government was unable to organize necessary medical assistance to the victims. There were no measures taken to block off traffic so that ambulances could quickly reach the hospitals, and physicians at the hospitals simply had no idea how to treat people poisoned by an unknown gas. Intheir lawsuits, they also pointed out that there was no effective investigation into the incident.

Comments (2) | Views: 5560| E-mail

Secrets of the Nord-Ost tragedy 9yearslater
, 26 2011

, 26 2011
Vladimir Kara-Murza: About 200people remembered victims of the terrorist attack on Dubrovka on its ninth anniversary. Thismorning relatives and friends of those who never returned from the play ‘Nord-Ost’ gathered on the square near the theater center. Theylaid flowers and released 130white balloons one for each of the victims into the sky. After a traditional minute of silence, they read the full list of victims, and then a requiem concert washeld.

Speaking before the participants were relatives of the victims, as well as singer-parliament member Joseph Kobzon, who nine years ago participated in the rescue of women and children. Thenthe children's radio and television choir performed, as well as several well-known Russian musicians. After the commemorations, the abbot of the temple under construction near the theatrical center held a memorial service for the victims of the terrorist attack.

The organizers of the commemoration announced that they have put together a book dedicated to the victims of ‘Nord-Ost’. Thebook includes short stories about each of the one hundred and thirty who were killed during the capture of theater.

Secrets of the ‘Nord-Ost’ tragedy 9years later. Weare now talking on this subject with Svetlana Gubareva, a former hostage, Alexander Cherkasov, a member of the board of the ‘Memorial’ human rights organization, and Elena Milashina, a columnist for ‘Novaya Gazeta’. Please tell us about this book that you are holding in your hands and that you showed to participants of today's commemoration.

Be first to comment this article | Views: 12932| E-mail

The book We Will Not Die
, 26 2011

The book We Will Not Die is released in time for the 9th anniversary of the tragedy at Dubrovka

ImageIn October 2002, terrorists took hostage nearly 1,000 artists and spectators of the musical Nord-Ost. 130could not be saved. Flowers and wreaths were laid by the memorial plaque, while white balloons were released into thesky.

Today in Russia they remember the victims of the tragedy at the theatrical center on Dubrovka. Victims and the loved ones of those who perished gathered by the building in Moscow. 9years ago, nearly 1000artists and members of the audience of the musical Nord-Ost were held hostage by terrorists. 130died. Amoment of silence was observed in their memory, while flowers and wreaths were laid by a memorial plaque and 130white balloons were released into the sky. Inaddition, on the anniversary of the tragedy a book devoted to the victims of the attack was published. Among its authors is a hostage.

Be first to comment this article | Views: 4572| E-mail

Karinna Moskalenko
, 25 1999

Karinna Moskalenko: “Besides the European Court, we do not have anything else we can count on”

   Rosa Malsagova / RFIKarinna Moskalenko, the attorney representing the ‘Nord-Ost’ victims at the European Court of Human Rights, talks about the case’s progress in Strasbourg, which has become became her clients’ lasthope.

October 24th marks the 9years from the date of the seizure of hostages in the theater on Dubrovka in Moscow. 912people had come to see the musical ‘Nord-Ost’, and on October 26th, 2002, during the assault 130of them were killed, according to official figures. Theinvestigation into the terrorist attack was called off in 2007, but reopened again thisyear.

Be first to comment this article | Views: 3130| E-mail

Nord-Ost A unfinished play for 130people
, 21 2011

Written by Zviad Mchedlishvili
Friday, October 21st, 2011

‘Nord-Ost’ an unfinished play for one hundred and thirty people. Ithas been nine years since the tragedy at Dubrovka. Whohad something to gain from the terrorist attack? Wasit possible to avoid an assault? Whydid the Russian authorities not let the terrorists release hostages? Morequestions than answers.

Musa Taipov, Anzor Maskhadov, Maxim Shevchenko, and Svetlana Gubareva on ‘Pulse of the Caucasus’ (Russian only)

Be first to comment this article | Views: 3595| E-mail

<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next > End >>

Results 57 - 63 of 298